|
Post by Whup Em All on Jan 11, 2022 11:31:22 GMT -6
Just to give us something to talk about during the football offseason, and because I'm legitimately curious about where the rest of you (mainly Gamecock fans) stand on CUSA expansion, I'm starting a new realignment thread. This one isn't for news or rumors or anything like that. It's just for killing time and having a bit of fun.
You've been appointed CUSA commissioner and have been given carte blanche to proceed with expansion however you desire. With that in mind:
1) Should CUSA add more teams? If not, why not?
2) If so, how many? What's your "ideal" number of conference teams - 9, 10, 11, 12, 14? And why?
3) What team(s) should be added, and why?
4) Finally, when all is said and done, what would your "final" CUSA look like? (Include divisions if necessary.)
Feel free to add whatever contingencies are necessary to achieve that final look. For example, maybe your plan requires the Mountain West Conference to expand and poach UTEP and NMSU, giving the CUSA footprint much more of a "southeastern" vibe than its current nation-spanning format. Whatever. Just account for everyone and try to keep it semi-realistic. (I add that not to put hard limits on anyone, but to try to make this a reasonable thought exercise to see where everyone's mind is. Otherwise, we can all just make up a crazy chain of events which results in the SEC inviting JSU. Would that be cool? Yes. Would it help see what your thoughts are on the future of CUSA? Not really, no.)
I have my own thoughts on this. I'll add them sometime later. Until then, go nuts.
Here's our starting point:
Liberty FIU WKU MTSU JSU La Tech SHSU UTEP NMSU
|
|
|
Post by ajc4jsu on Jan 11, 2022 14:03:28 GMT -6
UTEP and NMSU go west. They are gone, Leaving us with 7. I Pitch to JMU, E Carolina, Ga State, UAB, Ark State, ULM, FAU , UCF, and Ga SOuth. This gives you 16 with 4 regional "pods".
LIBERTY, WKU, JMU, E Carolina. JSU, MTSU, GA State, UAB La Tech, SHSU, ULM, Ark State FAU, UCF, Ga South, FIU
This would present decent travel and regional rivalries.
Like you say, this is living in a dream world.
|
|
|
Post by JSUSoutherner on Jan 11, 2022 15:00:26 GMT -6
UTEP and NMSU go west. They are gone, Leaving us with 7. I Pitch to JMU, E Carolina, Ga State, UAB, Ark State, ULM, FAU , UCF, and Ga SOuth. This gives you 16 with 4 regional "pods". LIBERTY, WKU, JMU, E Carolina. JSU, MTSU, GA State, UAB La Tech, SHSU, ULM, Ark State FAU, UCF, Ga South, FIU This would present decent travel and regional rivalries. Like you say, this is living in a dream world. I understand this is a dream scenario but I think an SEC invite may be more likely.
|
|
|
Post by stinkypete on Jan 11, 2022 15:16:39 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by cockyfriend on Jan 11, 2022 15:55:50 GMT -6
I just want KSU and UTC. Mainly for the rivalries.also for the footprint.
|
|
|
Post by troysux on Jan 11, 2022 16:00:01 GMT -6
I would like to see us get at least one more right now to give us a buffer in case anyone leaves. I’m not going to speculate who might leave as that is beyond our control. Yes, it would be great to unload the far west members but I don’t see the MWC expanding unless they lose a couple. It would be great if the AAC decided FAU needed a neighbor but I don’t expect that to happen.
First, who I don’t want.
Non-football members. It is a CUSA rule you must sponsor football and I don’t want that to change. It is a way of life to have mixed leagues in FCS but we have left that behind. The Sun Belt has run off UALR and UTA is looking for a home. No, Stevo, I don’t hate basketball, I just want everyone to sponsor football.
I also don’t want football-only members. Navy and Hawaii are football affiliates in their leagues but both are special cases. Notre Dame is a partial football member of the ACC and I think they may eventually be forced to join full time.
That leaves three true independents.
Army-They were a football affiliate in CUSA 1998-2004 and went 9-41 in league play and had an 0-13 season in 2003. Their fortunes have improved lately but seem to like being independent. If they ever join a conference again it would probably be with Navy. Not to sound un-American, but I’d rather not have them but if we had to have an affiliate, it would be them.
UMASS-They were in the MAC for football but got kicked out because they wouldn’t go all in. Outside of the Calipari years, their basketball isn’t that great. And their football (once an FCS power) is even worse. I could live with them as a full member but I’d rather not and definitely not football only.
UCONN-A former G5 power, they have also declined in recent years. They pissed off someone in the ACC as they got left behind. They definitely wouldn’t come here for Olympics and their football doesn’t add much. I would be fine with them as a full member but not an affiliate.
I don’t see any current FBS schools coming here. It doesn’t hurt to ask but I expect everyone in the Sun Belt would turn us down.
That leaves our options in the FCS. How many should we get? I would prefer going with nine for a year or two to get the new league settled and let us and Sammy finish our transition. Then take one to get to ten and then a couple more and stop. Twelve should be the max for a one bid league anyway.
As spread out as we are, it at least helps if everyone has a travel partner. That gives you a close rival for games and makes it easy to get a pair of games in on a road trip without a second plane flight or a long bus ride. Let’s go through the list and see what we can do.
My suggestions for new members are just guesses. I have no idea if any of them have the desire or the ability to move up.
NMSU/UTEP-They are 42 miles apart and probably thrilled to be conference rivals at last. They’d probably leave as a pair if the MWC lost two members but that’s a discussion for another day. Unfortunately, both are over 700 miles from Sam Houston. That sucks for everyone but they have each other, which is more than the rest of the league can say.
Sam Houston/LaTech-They are 260 miles apart. Not close, but not too far away, especially for this league. Tech is stuck here as the other Louisiana schools seem to hate them, based on message board chatter. To help them out, I would invite Stephen F. Austin. They are 98 from Sam and 162 from Tech.
WKU/MTSU-They are 89 miles apart but a 2:39 (!) drive. WKU wanted to go to the MAC but MTSU wouldn’t go with them. So maybe some bad blood there. If UMASS ever agrees to full MAC membership (or if Buffalo goes to the AAC) WKU is probably gone. But they are here for now and they are a pair.
Jacksonville State-We are 191 miles from MTSU and 273 from WKU. Not too bad if you only can make one road trip per season. But to help us out, I would go after Chattanooga. Only 114 miles apart. They are also 104 from MTSU, which would be an incentive to keep them around. I honestly don’t think they want FBS, so my second call would be to Kennesaw. They are 84 miles from JSU and puts the league in Atlanta. Nobody in Atlanta cares, but they do have a major airport. Chattanooga doesn’t sponsor baseball. This is actually a point in their favor as UTEP doesn’t have baseball so it keeps that at an even number.
Liberty-They are up there a ways. They are 479 from MTSU, 493 from WKU, and 509 from us. They are 290 from Delaware but just 107 from NC A&T. I would call A&T first. Taking in an HBCU would be good publicity for the league.
FIU-Not much we can do for them. They are 806 miles from us. The only other FCS in Florida are Florida A&M (525 miles) and Bethune-Cookman. A&M tried FBS for a year once and it was a disaster. As I said above, our best hope is the AAC takes them, but that is unlikely. Or maybe they drop to FCS or drop football altogether. But we are stuck with them.
So this gives us these divisions:
NMSU UTEP Sam Houston La Tech FIU Stephen F. Austin
JSU WKU MTSU Liberty NC A&T Chattanooga/Kennesaw
I put FIU in the West as they are a long haul for everyone as it is.
I know this post makes whup’s look short but I hope you enjoyed it. I tried to keep it as realistic as possible.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
|
|
Post by gemofthehills on Jan 11, 2022 16:19:06 GMT -6
If I knew if a new agreement was coming to expand the payout to more than 10 members, then I could pick/guess better.
If it stays at ten, look for some school towards the western part. Missouri St, SFA, UCA, McNeese?
If it expands to more schools say 14 then it could get wild in the ideas. Add NDSU, SDSU and UNI to the above and pick 3
UTC, EKU or KSU pick two added to the east.
|
|
|
Post by sinfoniansoutherner1 on Jan 11, 2022 22:14:07 GMT -6
Maybe my first reply on this board? Was on the last one. Good to see y’all, hope all is well!
On Kennesaw and UTC, I do have some *limited* insight.
My uncle is on the board at Kennesaw and an alum. My dad is a large donor and supporter at UTC. And here I am, an alum of Jax State. The holidays are a joy.
Kennesaw is going through some struggles on expanding. They are essentially “land locked”. They’re trying to decide on how to continue to build the main campus, but do not see a path to expand the football stadium without building a brand new one off campus. They won’t go FBS until they can build a fan base to fill as 20,000+ new stadium.
UTC is in the process of exploring options. Still trying to get their attendance back to the Huesman days. Starting to get better, attempting to be on a 5 year plan with Sunbelt hopes. They would be a good target for CUSA. Chattanooga is starting to modernize, and is a great place to live now. Would also be our instant rival.
All that to say, don’t hold out hopes for Kennesaw. It’s going to be a long while for them.
|
|
|
Post by Cleburneslim on Jan 12, 2022 5:20:43 GMT -6
Realistic (as far as I can tell) East west split.
East
Wku MTSU Liberty EKU or NCAT JSU UTC FIU
West
La Tech UCA or SELA SHSU SFA Abilene Christian or Tarleton UTEP NMSU
7/7 possibly 8/8. Split or better yet 4 pods with the 1st fbs 4 team conference championship playoff.
|
|
|
Post by gemofthehills on Jan 12, 2022 6:32:06 GMT -6
Best to remember (IMO) to pick the best fits whether you have the option of FBS or FCS. Unless you could luck up and get Army/Navy then none of the prospects have any brand value. As soon as JMU, Sam and JSU hit the FBS our brand value will be on par with 90% or better of the G5 schools. Amazing how many of the people I know from around the country still consider troy state, UAB, App, Marshall and several other low level FBS schools DII. Folks are not putting them in the same level as UAT and UGA no matter how much we or they scream.
|
|
|
Post by Cleburneslim on Jan 12, 2022 6:38:29 GMT -6
True
|
|
|
Post by ksig2014 on Jan 12, 2022 8:03:49 GMT -6
Maybe my first reply on this board? Was on the last one. Good to see y’all, hope all is well! On Kennesaw and UTC, I do have some *limited* insight. My uncle is on the board at Kennesaw and an alum. My dad is a large donor and supporter at UTC. And here I am, an alum of Jax State. The holidays are a joy. Kennesaw is going through some struggles on expanding. They are essentially “land locked”. They’re trying to decide on how to continue to build the main campus, but do not see a path to expand the football stadium without building a brand new one off campus. They won’t go FBS until they can build a fan base to fill as 20,000+ new stadium. UTC is in the process of exploring options. Still trying to get their attendance back to the Huesman days. Starting to get better, attempting to be on a 5 year plan with Sunbelt hopes. They would be a good target for CUSA. Chattanooga is starting to modernize, and is a great place to live now. Would also be our instant rival. All that to say, don’t hold out hopes for Kennesaw. It’s going to be a long while for them. Kennesaw st pups easily add another level to their football stadium. Plenty of space out there. KSU always needs to purchase office buildings and Townscenter mall area. They are struggling to put a competitive product right now. Baseball has been struggling, basketball has the right coach but still building and they are not good at anything else yet.
|
|
|
Post by ksig2014 on Jan 12, 2022 8:04:28 GMT -6
Don’t get me wrong Kennesaw St has more potential than us and would love them in whatever conference we are in
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 12, 2022 9:29:08 GMT -6
Probably need to get to 14 teams and split into two divisions eventually. All the other conferences are going to be bloated too. I'm finally coming around to the FBS for JSU. We're not ever going to be competing for a national championship until the ACC or SEC start calling after a nuclear apocalypse, but I realize that the FCS is dying outside of NDSU and bowl games are exciting. Winning our conference will be on the table and I think we will have the ability to win against schools with well known helmets.
|
|
|
Post by Whup Em All on Jan 12, 2022 10:39:22 GMT -6
Best to remember (IMO) to pick the best fits whether you have the option of FBS or FCS. Unless you could luck up and get Army/Navy then none of the prospects have any brand value. As soon as JMU, Sam and JSU hit the FBS our brand value will be on par with 90% or better of the G5 schools. Amazing how many of the people I know from around the country still consider troy state, UAB, App, Marshall and several other low level FBS schools DII. Folks are not putting them in the same level as UAT and UGA no matter how much we or they scream. Careful, Gem. That kinda talk'll get you banned by the Sun Belt mods on CSNBBS... I think you were on to something with the "best fits" comment, though. It's like picking for the NFL Draft -- you either have to draft the best player available or you draft for need. Sometimes it's an easy choice. Other times, not so much... Over in the eastern side of the footprint, we have several teams who look promising, though some of them may not be ready, or able, or even willing to move. The ASUN teams are at the top of that list, of course, with KSU and EKU, but then there's UTC and NCAT. Any of these teams would be a solid addition, I think. Over in the west, throw in UCA, since they've indicated a willingness to move up, and SFA, who pairs well with SHSU. And Missouri State is another prime candidate out that way. Those are your "easy" choices. After that, you're taking some big risks. Tarleton, Lamar, Abilene Christian... I've even seen people mention the other JSU, which is close to a no-brainer pick right now, but will only retain that status as long as Coach Prime remains in Jackson. The Dakotas are intriguing, but we'd either be adding a football-only member or we'd have an awkward travel footprint for OLY sports. I mean, one that makes the current footprint look attractive. I agree with several of you that there are no realistic (read: good) FBS options out there. UMass and UConn are a hard no from me. Notre Dame is not happening. Army is probably not happening. So what are we left with? Just those FCS candidates. And regardless of who gets the call and who doesn't, the one sure thing there is, we don't need to rush it. EKU may be ready today, but they'll be even more ready next year. Or in two years. KSU probably needs 5 years at least. Same with UCA and NCAT. Honestly, I'm not sure SHSU was even ready. (Obviously, the strength of their football team is not in question.) JSU was ready, but only because we've been actively working toward it since the days of Jack Crowe, when today's incoming freshmen were still watching Barney and The Wiggles unironically. I'm still working on my best case dream scenario. I'm hung up on the final number, and divisions and pods and all that stuff. It's tougher than I expected it to be, once you move past football. I can see why so many people are happy with 9 teams...
|
|